Updated: April 21st, 2012 9:43pm
Carl Pavano makes one big mistake, loses duel to Tampa's James Shields

Carl Pavano makes one big mistake, loses duel to Tampa's James Shields

by The Associated Press
SportsWire Daily

Get the 1500 ESPN SportsWire delivered to your inbox daily, and keep up with all the news in Twin Cities Sports


ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. -- Carl Pavano make one key mistake, and that was all James Shields needed.

Shields carried a three-hitter into the ninth inning, B.J. Upton had a key two-run single and the Tampa Bay Rays beat the Minnesota Twins 4-1 on Saturday night.

"A tough night at the plate, but guys like that do that to you," Twins manager Ron Gardenhire said. "We were facing a very, very good pitcher out there, Mr. Shields. He was really, really good. He's a gamer. He dominated us."

The skinny

Shields (3-0) allowed one run and five hits over eight-plus innings while winning his third consecutive start after getting a no-decision on opening day against the New York Yankees.

"I thought it was a good pitcher's duel, going back and forth," Pavano said. "Overall, we were in it until the end."

Upton's two-out hit off Pavano (1-2) gave the Rays a 3-0 lead in the sixth. Another run scored on the play when center fielder Denard Span was charged with a throwing error attempting to cut down Matt Joyce at third.

"That was the deciding factor," Pavano said. "I left a pitch up and he jammed shot it into center field."

Pavano gave up three runs and seven hits in six innings. He threw 110 pitches.

"They made him work really hard," Gardenhire said. "He gave a great chance to win, it was just the other guy on the other side really didn't let us do anything. Carl went toe to toe with him, then finally cracked there a little bit."

Shields was pulled in the ninth after allowing Willingham's hit and a double by Justin Morneau. Ryan Doumit had a sacrifice fly off Fernando Rodney, who picked up his fifth save.

Aided by two errors and a hit batter, Tampa Bay took a 4-0 lead in the seventh on Evan Longoria's grounder. Longoria has seven RBIs over the past three games.

Pavano induced a double-play grounder from Upton with runners on first and third in the fourth, ending the threat. One inning later, Joe Mauer, playing first base, made a diving catch on Desmond Jennings' one-out squeeze bunt and doubled Jose Molina off third.

Turning point

Shields threw 29 pitches during the sixth inning. But he got out of a bases-loaded jam when Doumit lined out to third for the final out of the inning.

Numbers game

• 15: Consecutive games in which Willingham has reached base to start the season, tying Kirby Puckett's Twins record and a franchise best for a player starting his Twins career.

• 2: Hits in four at-bats for Mauer, who is 33-for-74 overall at Tropicana Field.

• 0: Hits in five at-bats for the Twins with runners in scoring position against Shields.

• 9: Consecutive home wins, dating to July 21, for the Rays with Shields on the mound. Shields is 7-0 in that stretch.

Health report

• Morneau finished 1 for 3 with a walk after not playing Friday night because of a sore right foot. "Still got a little soreness in his foot, but he ready's to get back out there," Twins manager Ron Gardenhire said. Morneau fouled a ball off the foot Thursday.

On deck

Sunday: at Tampa Bay, 12:40 p.m. Twins LHP Francisco Liriano (0-2, 11.91 earned-run average) vs. Rays RHP Jeff Niemann (0-2, 4.50). "If (Liriano) has his fastball command, look out," Rays manager Joe Maddon said.

© The Associated Press