LIVE › 9-10 a.m. Tee Time
NEXT › 10:05 a.m. Saturday SportsTalk
12:05 p.m. Money Talk with Josh Arnold
1:05 p.m. This Week in High School Sports
2:05 p.m. SportsCenter Saturday
Updated: September 2nd, 2011 12:46am
Pelissero: Starters mostly set, but Vikings' backup plans are clouded

Pelissero: Starters mostly set, but Vikings' backup plans are clouded

SportsWire Daily

Get the 1500 ESPN SportsWire delivered to your inbox daily, and keep up with all the news in Twin Cities Sports

by Tom Pelissero

MINNEAPOLIS -- The Minnesota Vikings wrapped the preseason on Thursday night with 26 contributors on the sideline and their backups rolling over the Houston Texans 28-0.

"Now, the real tough part of the job begins," Vikings coach Leslie Frazier said. "With such a great effort from so many (Thursday) night, it's going to make it tough for our staff to finalize that 53-man roster, which is a good problem to have."

Coaches and personnel men will begin the final evaluation process early Friday morning. By 5 p.m. Saturday, they'll have made 27 moves -- at least -- to reduce the roster from 80.

The only clouded starting jobs are at strong safety and punt returner. And although the Vikings surely entered Thursday with a strong sense of who would make the cut, those final 60 minutes may have raised a couple more questions they have 1½ days to resolve.

"I was talking to Rick Spielman (the Vikings' vice president of player personnel) earlier about just that fact," Frazier said. "We're going to have some strong discussions (Friday) at certain positions, and we've got to be able to make some good decisions and realizing that there may be some good football players that may not make our team, but there are some good football players that will."

The following is an educated guess at how the roster might shake out, not including trades or other acquisitions, and the issues that will influence the final decisions:

Quarterbacks (3)

In: Donovan McNabb, Christian Ponder, Joe Webb.

Key question: Did Ponder do enough to take the No. 2 job over Webb? He finished 10-of-17 passing for 83 yards, a score and a 91.1 rating on Thursday, leading two touchdown drives, but continued to appear out of sorts when he stayed in the pocket. The rookie also scrambled eight times for 61 yards, including a 15-yarder on a broken play to set up the first touchdown. Webb was 5-of-6 passing for 43 yards and a 96.5 rating, plus one rush for 12, and led a pair of 11-play touchdown drives after taking over in the third quarter. Either way, there's no 53-man decision here. All three will be on the roster.

Running backs (3)

In: Lorenzo Booker, Toby Gerhart, Adrian Peterson.

Out: Matt Asiata, Tristan Davis, Ryan D'Imperio, Caleb King, Alexander Robinson.

Key question: Are either of the fullbacks worth keeping? The short answer is no, although D'Imperio probably had his best game on Thursday. Asiata has an intriguing skill set but probably belongs on the practice squad for now. The Vikings could comb the waiver wire and the street for an alternative, or they could flex their tight ends into the backfield even more than they did in the preseason. Davis worked ahead of Robinson and King, who didn't play until the third quarter but impressed with 19 carries for 62 yards and two scores. The injuries that sidelined Gerhart (ankle/Achilles) and Booker (back) of late aren't expected to keep them out of the Sept. 11 opener at San Diego, so the Vikings probably will try to slip King through to the practice squad. That might have gotten a little more difficult after the way he played on Thursday.

Receivers (5)

In: Greg Camarillo, Devin Aromashodu, Bernard Berrian, Percy Harvin, Michael Jenkins.

Out: Emmanuel Arceneaux, Stephen Burton, Juaquin Iglesias, Jaymar Johnson.

Key question: Are Camarillo's sure hands and special-teams ability worth $1.725 million? If not, draw straws between Arceneaux, Iglesias and Johnson, who worked ahead of the other two on Thursday but has minimal value if he's not the starting punt returner. Aromashodu isn't a lock for the roster, especially after going without a catch the final two preseason games. But he probably is the best special teamer of the bunch and has the most NFL playing experience. Arceneaux just hasn't gotten many opportunities.

Tight ends (4)

In: Jeff Dugan, Jimmy Kleinsasser, Kyle Rudolph, Visanthe Shiancoe.

Out: Allen Reisner.

Key question: Are the Vikings willing to risk losing Reisner on waivers, as they did last season with Mickey Shuler? If not, there's an outside chance they could keep him over Dugan, whose blocking ability probably will let him hang on if the Vikings go without a fullback. Shiancoe missed the entire preseason with hamstring problems, but he's expected to practice on Monday and isn't believed to be in trouble, despite a $3.1 million base salary and $4.2 million cap number.

Offensive linemen (9)

In: Ryan Cook, Jon Cooper, Chris DeGeare, Anthony Herrera, Steve Hutchinson, Charlie Johnson, Phil Loadholt, DeMarcus Love, John Sullivan.

Out: Patrick Brown, Brandon Fusco, Byron Isom, Seth Olsen, Thomas Welch.

Key question: Will an experienced tackle/guard hit the street on Saturday? The Vikings signed Scott Kooistra to fill that role, but he broke his neck in Seattle. They also brought in Cook, but he's mostly an inside player at this stage, leaving only DeGeare -- who probably belongs at guard and missed Thursday's game because of a concussion -- to back up the edge if Loadholt or Johnson goes down. Love's potential probably gives him the edge over Brown, who was claimed off waivers twice last season. Waiving Fusco would be a risk, especially after the way he blocked on Thursday, but he has a long way to go before he's ready to contribute.

Defensive linemen (9)

In: Jared Allen, Adrian Awasom, Remi Ayodele, Christian Ballard, Fred Evans, Everson Griffen, Letroy Guion, Brian Robison, Kevin Williams.

Out: David Akinniyi, Tremaine Johnson, Cedric McKinley, D'Aundre Reed, Stylez G. White.

Key question: Is Evans the Vikings' only backup plan at nose tackle? If so, he'll make the team, despite a lackluster 2010 and a typically uneven preseason. Reed flashed in training camp before a calf slowed him down, probably relegating him to the practice squad. White had a sack on Thursday and might have something left at age 32. But Awasom and Griffen were two of the Vikings' camp stars and there only are so many snaps to go around behind Allen and Robison.

Linebackers (6)

In: Heath Farwell, Chad Greenway, E.J. Henderson, Erin Henderson, Ross Homan, Kenny Onatolu.

Out: Jasper Brinkley (injured reserve), Larry Dean, David Herron.

Key question: Who would be the next man in if one of the Vikings' starting linebackers goes down? Brinkley had the most playing time on defense of this group, but it's hard to imagine the Vikings waiting two months or more for him to recover from hip surgery. Herron started three games for the Vikings in 2008 but none since. Farwell is a career special teamer with a $1.75 million base salary. Onatolu still doesn't look right after missing time with a stress fracture in his foot. Dean might have been in position to grab one of the last spots until Thursday, when he had two penalties on special teams and appeared lost on defense. Homan has upside as a three-position backup but didn't flash much in the preseason. This position group easily is the toughest to peg -- no combination of backups would be surprising, and the Vikings may look outside for insurance.

Defensive backs (11)

In: Husain Abdullah, Asher Allen, Brandon Burton, Chris Cook, Eric Frampton, Cedric Griffin, Tyrell Johnson, Mistral Raymond, Jamarca Sanford, Marcus Sherels, Antoine Winfield.

Out: Tony Carter, Ryan Hill">Ryan Hill, Cord Parks, Devon Torrence.

Key question: Who's the starting strong safety? Because if it's Sanford, there's at least a chance the Vikings would consider cutting their losses with Johnson, the former second-round pick who lost the job in camp last year, dropped an interception on Thursday and has a $922,250 cap number in the last year of his rookie deal. Otherwise, they'd be going five-deep at safety to retain a player who brings little on special teams. The guess here is the Vikings personnel department isn't ready to give up on Johnson just yet. The toe injury that has cost Allen a couple of weeks is a question mark, too, although Frazier indicated it wouldn't keep him out in Week 1. Sherels, who also figures as the punt returner, and Burton came on strong over the past couple of weeks and may have passed Allen on the depth chart anyway.

Specialists (3)

In: Chris Kluwe, Cullen Loeffler, Ryan Longwell.

Key question: None here, despite Longwell's somewhat uninspiring preseason. It'll be the same group the Vikings have had since 2006.

Tom Pelissero is Senior Editor and columnist for He hosts from 6 to 8 p.m. weeknights and co-hosts from 10 a.m. to noon Sundays on 1500 ESPN Twin Cities.
Email Tom | @TomPelissero | Tom Pelissero
In this story: Husain Abdullah, David Akinniyi, Asher Allen, Jared Allen, Emmanuel Arceneaux, Devin Aromashodu, Matt Asiata, Adrian Awasom, Remi Ayodele, Christian Ballard, Bernard Berrian, Lorenzo Booker, Jasper Brinkley, Patrick Brown, Brandon Burton, Stephen Burton, Greg Camarillo, Ryan Cook, Chris Cook, Jon Cooper, Ryan D'Imperio, Tristan Davis, Larry Dean, Chris DeGeare, Jeff Dugan, Fred Evans, Heath Farwell, Eric Frampton, Leslie Frazier, Brandon Fusco, Toby Gerhart, Chad Greenway, Everson Griffen, Cedric Griffin, Letroy Guion, Percy Harvin, E.J. Henderson, Erin Henderson, Anthony Herrera, Ryan Hill, Ryan Hill, Ross Homan, Steve Hutchinson, Juaquin Iglesias, Byron Isom, Michael Jenkins, Jaymar Johnson, Charlie Johnson, Tremaine Johnson, Tyrell Johnson, Caleb King, Jimmy Kleinsasser, Chris Kluwe, Scott Kooistra, Phil Loadholt, Cullen Loeffler, Ryan Longwell, DeMarcus Love, Cedric McKinley, Donovan McNabb, Seth Olsen, Kenny Onatolu, Cord Parks, Adrian Peterson, Christian Ponder, Mistral Raymond, D'Aundre Reed, Allen Reisner, Alexander Robinson, Brian Robison, Kyle Rudolph, Jamarca Sanford, Marcus Sherels, Visanthe Shiancoe, Mickey Shuler, John Sullivan, Devon Torrence, Joe Webb, Thomas Welch, Stylez G. White, Kevin Williams, Antoine Winfield